Effects of silvicultural thinning in planted stands on surface and crown wildfire behavior (Case study: Malekroud districts of Siahkal Forest)

Jahdi, Roghayeh; Arabi, Mahdi

doi:10.22111/jneh.2023.42189.1896

Effects of silvicultural thinning in planted stands on surface and crown wildfire behavior (Case study: Malekroud districts of Siahkal Forest)

Document Type : Research Article

Authors

Roghayeh Jahdi ¹
Mahdi Arabi ²

¹ Assistant Professor of Forest Sciences, Faculty of Agriculture and Natural Resources, University of Mohaghegh Ardabili, Ardabil, Iran

² Associate Professor of Surveying, Department of Surveying and Geomatics Engineering, Shahid Rajaee Teacher Training University, Tehran, Iran

10.22111/jneh.2023.42189.1896

Abstract

Under rapid climate change, desertification, and land degradation, a critical management issue in forests of northern Iran is how to increase forest resilience to wildfires. For decades, forest managers have been employing silvicultural treatments to restore the Hyrcanian forest stand's structure, composition, and diversity, but there is no scientific evidence to support that these treatments reduce the wildfire risk in the area. In this study, based on the wildfire behavior modeling approach using FlamMap MTT, we evaluated spatial relationships between silvicultural fuel reduction treatment (e.g., thinning) and surface and crown burn probabilities in the 6 and 7 Malekroud districts of Siahkal forest. We first analyzed fuel characteristics after the development of silvicultural treatments in the period 2007-2017 in the study area to evaluate low thinning and heavy thinning as restoration tools for similar fuel conditions. Furthermore, we conducted analyses of variance to determine the influence of the silvicultural thinning treatment on surface and canopy burn probabilities. Modeling results at the landscape scale confirm the important role of thinning in the mitigation of crown burn probability (almost 11%) in the study area. However, the effect of thinning on the surface burn probability was not statistically significant (P> 0.05). Comparing the two types of thinning in terms of intensity, heavy thinning had a greater effect on changing the surface and crown (i.e., 10% increase and 39% decrease, respectively, in conifer plantation) burn probability than the low thinning. The modeling approach in the study offers new insights to improve the spatial mapping of wildfire likelihood, include variables sensitive to thinning operation in the models, and provide useful information to prevent extreme wildfire behavior through effective silvicultural treatments.

Keywords

Main Subjects

Environmental Hazards

References

References (in Persian)

Abed, H., Sahraeyan, F. and Rezaei, P. (2016). The Effects of Garmesh Wind on Weather Conditions of Rasht Synoptic Weather Station. Geography and Environmental Hazards, 4 (2), pp 59-76. [In Persian]

Amin Amlashi M., Ghodskhah, M., Bonyad, A.I., Pourbabaei, H., Jafari, M., and Gholami, V. (2015). Evaluation of fuel load following a fire in Loblolly Pine (Pinus taeda L.) plantations using line sampling and of FLM method (Case study: Takhsam plantations in Guilan Province). Iranian Journal of Forest and Popular Research, 23 (3), pp 562-572. [In Persian]

Forouzesh-Sotgavaberi, R., Ahmadi M.T., Etemad, V. and Saeidi, H.R. (2009). Investigation on quantitative and qualitative characteristics of 19-years old plantation of Caucasian alder (Alnus subcordata) in Siahkal region. Iranian Journal of Forest, 1(2), pp 137-150. [In Persian]

General Office of Natural Resources and Watershed of Guilan Province. (2000). Forest Management Plan of District 1 of Malekroud, Guilan. [In Persian]

General Office of Natural Resources and Watershed of Guilan Province. (2010). Forest Management Plan of Districts 6 and 7 of Malekroud, Guilan. [In Persian]

Jahdi, R., Arabi, M. (2023). Surface and Crown Fuels and Wildfire Behavior in Natural and Planted Forests Ecosystem of the Watershed of 25 (Shenroud, Siahkal). Journal of Environmental Sciences Studies, 8 (2), 6373-6387. [In Persian]

Jahdi, R. (2021). Surface Fuel Models and Fire Hazard in Golestan National Park. Journal of Natural Ecosystems of Iran, 12(2), pp 82-99. [In Persian]

Jahdi, R., Ghorbani, A., Sefidi, K. (2020). Survey of wildfire simulation using FARSITE model (case study: Yeylagh Gasre Dagh, Meshgin Shahr Municipality). Journal of Natural Environmental Hazards, 9 (25), pp 171-190. [In Persian]

Jahdi, R., Darvishsefat, A.A. and Etemad, V. (2016). Assessing the Impact of Fuel Moisture Conditions on Fire Spread and Behavior in Golestan National Park. Journal of Forest and Wood Products, 68 (4), pp 799-813. [In Persian]

Jahdi, R., Darvishsefat, A.A. and Etemad, V. (2014). Predicting forest fire spread using fire behavior model (Case study: Malekroud Forest-Siahkal). Iranian Journal of Forest, 5 (4), pp 419-430. [In Persian]

Khoshdel, N., Rezaei, P., Motevali, S. and Janbaz Ghobadi, G.H. (2019). Explaining the tourism climate of the east of Guilan province using the physiological equivalent temperature. Journal of Studies of Human Settlements Planning, 15(4), pp 1119-1136. [In Persian]

Nasiri, M., Hojjati, S.M. and Tafazoli, M. (2012). Simulation of surface fire to study the spread rate of it`s distribution in mixed hardwood. Iranian Journal of Forest and Popular Research, 20 (1), pp 50-61. [In Persian]

Rahimi, D., Khademi, S. (2018). Analysis synoptic patterns for forest fires risk in northern of Iran. Journal of Natural Environmental Hazards, 7 (17), pp 19-36. [In Persian]

References (in English)

Agee, J.K. and Skinner, C.N. (2005). Basic principles of forest fuel reduction treatments. Forest Ecology and Management, 211, pp 83–96.

Alcasena, F.J., Ager, A.A., Bailey, J.D., Pineda, N. and Vega-García, C. (2019). Towards a comprehensive wildfire management strategy for Mediterranean areas: Framework development and implementation in Catalonia, Spain. Journal of Environmental Management, 231, pp 303-320.

Alcasena, F.J., Salis, M. and Vega-García, C.A. (2016). A fire modeling approach to assess wildfire exposure of valued resources in central Navarra, Spain. European Journal of Forest Research, 135, pp 87–107.

Arellano-Pérez, S., Castedo-Dorado, F., Álvarez-González, J.G., Alonso-Rego, C., Vega, J.A. and Ruiz-González, A.D. (2020). Mid-term effects of a thin-only treatment on fuel complex, potential fire behavior and severity and post-fire soil erosion protection in fast-growing pine plantations. Forest Ecology and Management, 460, 117895.

Beverly, J.L., Leverkus, S.E.R., Cameron, H. and Schroeder, D. (2020). Stand-level fuel reduction treatments and fire behavior in Canadian Boreal Conifer Forests. Fire, 3(3), 35.

Carey, H. and Schumann, M. (2003). Modifying wildfire behavior—the effectiveness of fuel treatments. Santa Fe, NM: National Community Forestry Center Southwest Region Working Paper #2.

Coen, J. (2018). Some Requirements for Simulating Wildland Fire Behavior Using Insight from Coupled Weather—Wildland Fire Models Janice Coen. Fire, 1(6), pp 1-18.

Finney, M.A. (2006). An overview of FlamMap fire modeling capabilities. In: Andrews, P.L., Butler, B.W. (Eds.), Fuels Management-How to Measure Success. US Department of Agriculture, Forest Service, Proceedings RMRS-P-41, p. 213-220.

Graham, R.T., McCaffrey, S. and Jain, T.B. (2004). Science basis for changing forest structure to modify wildfire behavior and severity. Gen. Tech. Rep. RMRS-GTR-120. Fort Collins, CO: U.S. Department of Agriculture, Forest Service, Rocky Mountain Research Station. 43 p. https://doi.org/10.2737/RMRS-GTR-120

Hirschberger, P. (2016). Forests ablaze: causes and effects of global forest fires.” Winter, S., von Laer, Y., Köberich, T., Eds (2016). 108p.

Johnston, J.D., Olszewski, J.H., Miller, B.A., Schmidt, M.R., Vernon, M.J. and Ellsworth, L.M. (2021). Mechanical thinning without prescribed fire moderate’s wildfire behavior in an Eastern Oregon, USA ponderosa pine forest. Forest Ecology and Management, 501, 119674.

Kalies, E.L. and Yocom Kent, L.L. (2016). Tamm Review: Are fuel treatments effective at achieving ecological and social objectives? A systematic review. Forest Ecology and Management, 375(2016), pp 84–95.

Keane R.E., Gray, K., Davis, B., Holsinger, L.M. and Loehman, R. (2019). Evaluating ecological resilience across wildfire suppression levels under climate and fuel treatment scenarios using landscape simulation modeling. International Journal of Wildland Fire, 28, pp 533-549.

Marshall, G., Thompson, D.K., Anderson, K., Simpson, B., Linn, R. and Schroeder, D. (2020). The Impact of Fuel Treatments on Wildfire Behavior 2 in North America Boreal Fuels: A Simulation Study 3 Using FIRETEC. Fire, 3, 18.

Mofidi, A., Soltanzadeh, I., Yousefi, Y., Zarrin, A., Soltani, M., Samakosh, J.M., Azizi, G., and Miller, S.T.K. (2015). Modeling the exceptional south Foehn event (Garmij) over the Alborz Mountains during the extreme forest fire of December 2005. Natural Hazards, 75, pp 2489–2518.

Omi, P.N. (2015). Theory and Practice of Wildland Fuels Management. Current Forestry Reports, 1, 100–117.

Palaiologou, P., Kalabokidis, K., Ager, A.A. and Day, M.A. (2020). Development of comprehensive fuel management strategies for reducing wildfire risk in Greece. Forests, 11, 789.

Piqué, M. and Domènech, R. (2018). Effectiveness of mechanical thinning and prescribed burning on fire behavior in Pinus nigra forests in NE Spain. The Science of the total environment, 618, pp 1539-1546.

Pollet, J. and Omi, P. (2002). Effect of thinning and prescribed burning on crown fire severity in ponderosa pine forests. International Journal of Wildland Fire, 11(1), pp 1-10.

Prichard, S.J., Povak, N.A., Kennedy, M.C. and Peterson, D.W. (2020). Fuel treatment effectiveness in the context of landform, vegetation, and large, wind-driven wildfires. Ecological Applications, 30(5), e02104.

Prichard, S.J., Peterson D.L. and Jacobson, K. (2010). Fuel treatments reduce the severity of wildfire effects in dry mixed conifer forest, Washington, USA. Canadian Journal of Forest Resources, 40, pp 1615–1626.

Pyne, S.J., Andrews, P.L. and Laven, R.D. (1996). Introduction to wildland fire. 2nd edition. New York, NY: John Wiley and Sons, Inc. 769 p.

Salis, M., Arca, B., Del Giudice, L., Palaiologou, P., Alcasena-Urdiroz, F., Ager, A.A., Fiori, M., Pellizzaro, G., Scarpa, C., Schirru, M., Ventura, A., Casula, M., Duce P. (2021). Application of simulation modeling for wildfire exposure and transmission assessment in Sardinia, Italy. International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction (IJDRR), 58, 102189.

Salis, M., Del Giudice, L., Arca, B., Ager, A.A., Alcasena, F.J., Lozano, O., Bacciu, V., Spano, D. and Duce, P. (2018). Modeling the effects of different fuel treatment mosaics on wildfire spread and behavior in a Mediterranean agro-pastoral area. Journal of Environmental Management, 212, pp 490–505.

Santoni, P.A., Filippi, J.B., Balbi, J.H. and Bosseur, F. (2011). Wildland Fire Behaviour Case Studies and Fuel Models for Landscape-Scale Fire Modeling. Journal of Combustion, 2011(613424), pp 1-12.

Schoennagel, T., Balch, J. K., Brenkert-Smith, H., Dennison, P. E., Harvey, B. J., Krawchuk, M. A., Mietkiewicz, N., Morgan, P., Moritz M.A., Rasker, R., Turner, M.G. and Whitlock, C. (2017). Adapt to more wildfire in western North American forests as climate changes. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 114, pp 4582–4590.

Stephens, S.L., Battaglia, M.A., Churchill, D.J., Collins, B.M., Coppoletta, M., Hoffman, C.M., Lydersen, J.M., North, M.P., Parsons R.A., Ritter, S.M., Stevens, J. (2021). Forest restoration and fuels reduction: convergent or divergent?. BioScience, 71, pp 85–101.

Thompson, D.K., Schroeder, D., Wilkinson, S.L., Barber, Q., Baxter, G., Cameron, H., Hsieh, R., Marshall, G., Moore, B., Refai, R., Rodell, C., Schiks, T., Verkaik, G.J., Zerb, J. (2020). Recent Crown Thinning in a Boreal Black Spruce Forest Does Not Reduce Spread Rate nor Total Fuel Consumption: Results from an Experimental Crown Fire in Alberta, Canada. Fire, 3, 28.

Turco, M., Rosa-Cánovas, J.J., Bedia, J., Jerez, S., Montávez, J.P., Llasat, M.C., Provenzale, A. (2018). Exacerbated fires in Mediterranean Europe due to anthropogenic warming projected with non-stationary climate-fire models. Nature Communications, 9(1), pp 1–9.

Taylor, C., Blanchard, W., Lindenmayer, D.B. (2021). Does forest thinning reduce fire severity in Australian eucalypt forests? Conservation Letters, 14 (2), 14:e12766.